SemesterSpring Semester, 2025
DepartmentGraduate Institute of Technology, Innovation & Intellectual Property Management, MA Program(IPM), First Year Graduate Institute of Technology, Innovation & Intellectual Property Management, MA Program(IPM), Second Year
Course NameThe Conflict Between Intellectual Property Rights and Competition Law and Its Reconciliation
Instructor
Credit2.0
Course TypeElective
Prerequisite
Course Objective
Course Description
Course Schedule







 


















































































































週次



Week



課程主題



Topic



課程內容與指定閱讀



Content and Reading Assignment



教學活動與作業



Teaching Activities and Homework



學習投入時間



Student workload expectation



課堂講授



In-class Hours



課程前後



Outside-of-class Hours



Week 1



6-9pm on May 29



Week 1 The Prelude



 



1.  The Merchant of Venice: A Metaphor for the Conflict



2. In the Realm of Trademark



3. In the Realm of Geographic Indication



4. In the Realm of Copyright



5. In the Realm of Patent



6. In the Realm of Designs



7. Trade Secret Protection



 8. After Services



 9. After IP Expires



10. Non-IP-Infringing But Unfair Practice



 



3



4.5



Week 2       6-9pm on May 31



Week 2 IP as Market Regulation To Enrich the Public Domain



 



 



 



 



 



 



1. In Search of a General Theory of IP



2. Proposing A Three-Step Exchange Theory of IP



3. IP Redefined and Reappreciated



4. IP and Protection Against Unfair Competition



5. IP as Part of the National Innovation System



6. IP’s Position within the General Legal System



 



 



3



4.5



Week 3      6-9pm on June 2  



Week 3   Market Competition and Competition Law



 



1. Introduction: Competition And Competition Law



2. Market and the Relevant Markets



3. General Competition Law



4. Sector-Specific Competition Laws



 



3



4.5



Week 4      6-9pm on June 3



Week 4 An IP Code, Its Principles, and A More Balanced International IP Regime



 



1.  Codification As A Means of State-Building



2. The Need of an IP Code



3. National IP Codes



4. Principles of An IP Code



5. A More Balanced International IP Regime



 



3



4.5



Week 5        6-9pm on June 5



Week 5



International IP Treaties and National IP Regimes on Compulsory Licensing



 



 



 



1. Introduction   



2.  Why Is Compulsory Trademark Licensing Not Allowed?



3. Compulsory Patent/Utility Model Licensing



4. Compulsory Copyright Licensing



5. Compulsory Design Licensing



6. Compulsory IC Layouts Licensing 



 



3



4.5



Week 6        6-9pm on June 7



Week 6 Competition-Oriented Compulsory Licensing of IPRs– Except Trademarks and GIs



 



1.  Compulsory IP Licensing Through Competition Law



2. Theoretical Analysis of a Competition-Oriented Compulsory Licensing



3. To Solve Two Thorny Issues



4. To Revise the TRIPS Agreement



 



3



4.5



Week 7        6-9pm on June 9



Part III Aggregating IP



 



Week 7 Patent Pools



1. The Development and Function of Patent Pools



2. The US  



3. The EU



4. Japan



5. Korea: Pools with Substitutes Or Non-Essential or Invalid Patents Likely Unjust



6. Taiwan: No Inclusion of Substitutes Into Pools



7. The PRC



8. The Governance of Patent Pools



   



 



3



4.5



Week 8        6-9pm on June 10



Week 8 Work Pools and Well-Known Trademarks Database



 



1.  Evolution of Modes of Exercising Copyright



2. Individual Licensing of Copyright



3. Work Pools



4. Database of Well-Known Trademarks



 



3



4.5



Week 9        6-9pm on June 12



Part IV FRANDly Licensing of SEPs



 



Week 9 SSOs, SEPs, And FRAND Licensing of SEPs        



 



1. SSOs



2. Antitrust Scrutiny of SSOs



3. SEPs



4. The Qualcomm Whirlwind



5. Major Issues Surrounding FRAND Licensing of SEPs



  



 



3



4.5



Week 10     6-9pm on June 14



Week 10 To Facilitate FRANDly Licensing of SEPs On A Global Scale



1. Introduction



2. Deficiencies of Current FRAND Licensing Framework



3. To Reconcile Conflicting Legal Standards Through Persuasion



4. To Rationalize the Calculation of FRAND-Compliant Rates



5. To Demand the Designated Major SSOs to Set Up A Competence Centre



6. Antitrust Intervenes When SSOs’ Self-Regulation Has Failed



 



3



4.5



Week 11       6-9pm on June 15



Student group presentation



 



 



3



4.5



Week 12      6-9pm on June 16



Student group presentation



 



 



3



4.5




 



 



Teaching Methods
Teaching Assistant

none


Requirement/Grading

Class participation   40%



Group presentation  20%



Term paper        40%


Textbook & Reference

 




  1. 劉孔中,解構智財權及其與競爭法的衝突與調和,2015年3月,新學林(獲科技部社科中心專書補助)。

  2. Kung-Chung Liu/Reto Hilty (ed.), Remuneration of Copyright Owners--Regulatory Challenges of New Business Models (Springer 2017)

  3. Kung-Chung Liu, The Problem with Trade Secret and Its Overprotection, 53 International Review of Industrial Property and Competition Law, No. 1, 94-115 (2022/1, SSCI)

  4. Kung-Chung Liu/ Reto Hilty, Compulsory Licensing─ Practical Experiences and Ways Forward, Max Planck Asian Intellectual Property Law Series Springer 2015.

  5. Kung-Chung Liu, Guaranteeing the Right to Fair Trial in IP-related Arbitration –in Germany Perhaps? and Elsewhere? 54 International Review of Industrial Property and Competition Law (2023/8, SSCI), 1-17.

  6. 劉孔中,智慧財產國際仲裁案件公平裁決的確保,月旦民商法雜誌82期(2023年12月),頁6-20。

  7. 劉孔中,智慧財產權法應該採用國際耗盡為原則,月旦法學雜誌349期(2024年6月),頁48-59。

  8. Kung-Chung Liu, Deciphering IP Law and Its Conflict and Complementarity with Competition Law‒Global Norms Against Asian Context (Routledge 2025)


Urls about Course
none
Attachment