SemesterFall Semester, 2023
DepartmentJunior Class of Department of Diplomacy
Course NameDebating Human Security: Justice, Equality, Humanity and Rights
InstructorWANG YUN
Credit3.0
Course TypeElective
Prerequisite
Course Objective
Course Description
Course Schedule




























































































































DATE



READING ASSIGNMENTS



TOPICS TO BE COVERED



W1



9/14




  1. Introduction



TED Talk video: Meg Jay “Why 30 is not the new 20,”




  1. Overview of the syllabus

  2. What are justice, equality, humanity and rights?

  3. How can “you” do about them?



W2



9/21




  1. Kaldor, ch.5 A Decade of Humanitarian Intervention,

  2. Owen and Liotta, 2006. “Why Human Security?” Whitehead Journal of Diplomacy and International Relations Vol VII, No. 1: 37-55.

  3. *Roland Paris, “Human Security: Paradigm Shift or Hot Air,” International Security, Vol. 26, N. 2, Fall 2001: 87-102.

  4. *PJ Burgess and Owen, “What is ‘Human Security’? Comments by 21 Authors” Security Dialogue, Vol. 35, No. 3, September 2004: 345-72.

  5. YouTube Video: New War 2.0: Interview with Kaldor



 




  1. Are there universal standards of justice, equality and rights?

  2. What is human security?

  3. Group preference due



(* are recommended readings)



 




  1. Human Rights



(Universality and Rights)



W3



9/28




  1. Kaldor, ch.2 or Kaldor 2003 “American Power from Compellance to Cosmopolitanism”

  2. Gary King and Christpher Murray, “Rethinking Human Security”

  3. *Donnelly, Jack. 2007. “The Relative Universality of Human Rights” Human Rights Quarterly 29(2)

  4. *Goodhart, Michael. 2008. “Neither Relative nor Universal: A Response to Donnelly” Human Rights Quarterly 30(1): 183-193



 




  1. Who’s security? Measurement of human security

  2. Universal rights?

  3. Cultural rights?

  4. Political rights and socioeconomic rights, which one should be first?



 



W4



10/5



 




  1. Thompson, Mark R.. “Pacific Asia after 'Asian Values': Authoritarianism, Democracy, and 'Good Governance'.” Third World Quarterly, Vol. 25, No. 6 (2004), pp. 1079-1095.

  2. Osofsky, Hari M.. “Understanding ‘Hostage-Diplomacy’: The Release of Wei Jingsheng and Wang Dan” Yale Human Rights & Development Law Journal 1 (1998).

  3. * Wachman, Alan. “Does the Diplomacy of Shame Promote Human Rights in China?” Third World Quarterly (2001).



 




  1. Expert Section 1

  2. Human Rights: the East and the West

  3. Asian values

  4. Case: Hostage diplomacy

  5. Exercise/Quiz 1



 



 




  1. Just War



(Stability and Responsibility)



W5



10/12




  1. Kaldor, Chapter 6 From Just War to Just Peace

  2. Owen, 2011, “R2P: More than a slogan”

  3. *Weiss, Thomas “The Sunset of Humanitarian Intervention? The R2P in a Unipolar Era,” Security Dialogue, 2004 35: 2: 135-153.    

  4. *Deitelhoff, Nicole, 2009. "The Discursive Process of Legalization: Charting Islands of Persuasion in the ICC Case," International Organization, 63(01): 33-65.

  5. *ICRC, “International Humanitarian Law in Brief”

  6. *Human Rights Watch, “Selling Justice Short,” 2009.

  7. *Scott Strauss, “Darfur and the Genocide Debate” Foreign Affairs, January/February 2005

  8. *Kenneth Roth, "The Law of War in the War on Terror," Foreign Affairs, January/February 2004.

  9. * Renatho Costa, "Religion and the New Wars Debate" Contexto International, 2019.



 




  1. Biopolitics

  2. SARS, MERS, Ebola, COVID-19 and more

  3. Biological security vs. Human rights

  4. What is City Wanderer?



 



W6



10/19




  1. Group 2 Presentation and Discussion

  2. TBA



 




  1. Expert Section 2

  2. Exercise/Quiz 2



W7



10/26




  1. City Wanderer discussion



 



CITY WANDERER© BEGIN



 




  1. Prepare City Wanderer projects



 




  1. Humanitarian Issues



(Issues of Justice and Humanity)



W8



11/2




  1. Michael Dillon, “Biopolitics of Security” in Handbook of New Security Studies (2010)

  2. Stefan Elbe, “Pandemic Security” in Handbook of New Security Studies (2010)

  3. Christian Enemark, “Is Pandemic Flu a Security Threat?” Survival (2009)

  4. Stefan Elbe, "AIDS, Security, Biopolitics," International Relations (2005)

  5. Multimedia: Pandemic Online game

  6. Movies: Contagion (2011)



 




  1. Just war theory and humanitarian intervention

  2. UN human security institutions

  3. R2P

  4. Landmine ban movement and transnational advocacy



W9



11/9




  1. Midterm Week



 



CITY WANDERER© REPORT DUE AND SHARING



 




  1. Case Study topic discussion



 



W10



11/16




  1. Kaldor, Chapter 5 or Kaldor 2003, “The idea of global civil society”

  2. Don Hubert, “The Landmine Treaty: A Case Study in Humanitarian Advocacy, Watson Jr. Institute for International Studies, Occasional Paper # 42, 2000, Chapter 5.

  3. *Thomas Weiss, 2006, “Principles, Politics, and Humanitarian Action” Ethics & International Affairs 13(1)



 




  1. Expert Section 3

  2. Case: Global Civil Society and Cosmopolitanism

  3. Just war theory in test: China or Africa

  4. Just war theory in test: torture

  5. Exercise/Quiz 3



 



 




  1. Trade and Immigration



(Development and Equality)



W11



11/23




  1. (Video) Pietra Rivoli. 2009. The Travels of a T-Shirt in the Global Economy

  2. Wu, Guoguang. 2013. “Human security challenges with China: why and how the rise of China makes the world vulnerable?”

  3. *Tarrow, Sidney G. 2005. The New Transnational Activism, New York: Cambridge University Press. Ch.1-2.

  4. *Yong Deng and Thomas G. Moore, “China Views Globalization: Toward a New Great-Power Politics?” The Washington Quarterly, 27 (3) (Summer 2004): 117 – 136.



GROUP CASE PAPER TOPIC DUE



 




  1. Globalization: its promises and opposition

  2. Anti-globalization activism

  3. MNCs and “race to the bottom”

  4. Case: China’s view toward globalization



W12



11/30




  1. Peggy Levitt, "’You Know, Abraham Was Really the First Immigrant’: Religion and Transnational Migration” International Migration Review, 37(3), Transnational Migration: International Perspectives (Fall, 2003): 847-873.

  2. *Cohen, Robin. 1997. Global Diasporas: An Introduction. Seattle: Univ. of Washington Press.



 




  1. Expert Section 4

  2. Immigration: a cultural right or economic right?

  3. Freedom of immigration?

  4. Exercise/Quiz 4



 




  1. Sustainable Politics



(Issues of Suitability)



W13



12/7




  1. Tim Hayward, 2007. “Human Rights versus Emissions Rights: Climate Justice and the Equitable Distribution of Ecological Space,” Ethics and International Affairs 21.4.

  2. *Tarrow, Sidney G.; Donatella Della Porta, 2005b. Transnational Protest and Global Activism‎ (print)

  3. *Romina Picolotti & Jorge Daniel Taillant eds. Linking Human Rights and the Environment. 2003



 



TED Talk by Paul Piff: Does Money Make You Mean



       




  1. Principal-agent theory

  2. Kyoto Protocol

  3. Environmental rights



 



W14



12/14




  1. Xie, 2011, “China's Environmental Activism in the Age of Globalization,” Asian Politics & Policy 3(2): 207–224.

  2. *Abigail R. Jahiel “The Organization of Environmental Protection in China,” The China Quarterly: 757-787.



 




  1. Expert Section 5

  2. Environmental activism in China

  3. Exercise/Quiz 5



 



W15



12/21




  1. Owen Taylor and Mary Martin, 2010. “The Second Generation of Human Security: Lessons from the UN and EU Experiences?” International Affairs, 85(1).

  2. *Owen, Taylor, 2008. The Critique that Doesn’t Bite: A Response to David Chandler’s “Human Security: The Dog that didn’t Bark” Security Dialogue, 39(4), April/June 2008.

  3. *Caprioli, Mary, “Democracy and Human Rights Versus Women’s Security: A Contradiction?” Security Dialogue 2004 35(4): 411-428.

  4. *Emilie Hafner-Burton and Kiyoteri Tsutsui, “Justice Lost!: The Failure of International Human Rights Law to Matter Where it is Needed Most” Journal of Peace Research (2007): 407-25.

  5. *Emilie Hafner-Burton and James Ron, “Seeing Double”



 



 




  1. Review: Justice, Equality, Humanity and Rights

  2. Second Generation HS

  3. Feminist view on HS



W16



12/28




  1. Group Assignment Discussion and Preparation



 




  1. TBA



W17



1/4




  1. Group Presentation




  1. TBA



W28



Final Exam Week 1/11



GROUP PAPER DUE



Teaching Methods
Teaching Assistant
Requirement/Grading


  1. In-class exercises and participation: 10%




  2. In-class quizzes: 30%




  3. Thought papers: 20%




  4. Research paper (group): 20%




  5. Presentation and round table (group): 20%




Textbook & Reference

Texts:



Mary Kaldor, Human Security. Polity Press (2007) [PDF]



Yoichi Mine, Oscar A. Gomez, Ako Muto, Human Security Norms in East Asia (2019) [ebook]



Andrew Crabtree, Sustainability, Capabilities and Human Security (2020) [ebook]



All selected chapters/articles are available on Moodle.


Urls about Course
Attachment